Tim Benz: NFL must listen to Cam Heyward and other defensive players on 'hip-drop' penalty consideration
If the NFL just wants to govern itself by Twitter, I hope it follows the account of Pittsburgh Steelers defensive end Cameron Heyward. Because at least he’s tweeting something reasonable.
No, seriously. Someone is actually doing that in 2023.
It appears the NFL is strongly considering the elimination of the “hip-drop” tackle. If you’ve never heard of that phrase before, don’t feel bad. Pretty much no one in the northern hemisphere had until the divisional round of the NFL playoffs.
A hip-drop is when the defender grabs the ball carrier from behind and then falls down the offensive player, dropping their body weight onto the ball carrier’s legs. That was the method of tackling used as Dallas Cowboys running back Tony Pollard suffered a leg fracture during a playoff game in San Francisco.
After Mahomes yesterday another textbook high ankle sprain mechanism for Tony Pollard. This one appears worse, additional concern for fracture. Hip drop tackle again too - not always a “dirty” play but a technique with high risk of injury to ball carrier pic.twitter.com/1Tl78OFkPo
— NRL PHYSIO (@nrlphysio) January 23, 2023
The day before, Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes was hurt on a similar play.
Some are calling Arden Key’s takedown of Patrick Mahomes dirty because of the way he lands on his leg. Others say he didn’t do anything wrong.
Thoughts on this play? pic.twitter.com/C84dgAsTr1
— ClutchPoints (@ClutchPointsApp) January 21, 2023
As video of those plays started to trend on Twitter, social media was overrun by a wave of pearl-clutchers insisting that the NFL had to outlaw such plays, because the National Rugby League in Australia had done so after a rash of similar injuries.
In Australia and for the game NRL (Rugby League) we have outlawed this tackle. We call it a Hip Drop. The way the defender loses his feet and drops his weight on the legs intentionally is very dangerous and often results in knee ligament injuries. NFL need to consider this!
— dangerpresent (@dangerpresent) January 23, 2023
Gotta ban that type of tackle period.
— Ray G (@RayGQue) January 23, 2023
In Australia that tackle is called a hip drop & is banned in rugby league.
Causes too many acl & high ankle injuries.
— Freakzilla (@Freakzilla316) January 23, 2023
The nfl doesn’t want you to know about hip drop tackles, which nearly wiped out two other star players this season https://t.co/gpkVJ3IXYB
— Phil Prior (@Phil_Prior) January 21, 2023
Following injuries to Pat Mahomes and in the Dallas v SF game over the past 2 days in the #NFLPlayoffs, the NFL really need to look into including the ‘Hip drop’ rule which is used by the NRL, really needs to be employed for player safety!!
— Matt Clark (@MattCla25500233) January 23, 2023
And, of course, the NFL is listening. Because if there is anything the NFL fears more than negative traction on Twitter, it’s potential player-safety lawsu…
Uh, I mean, the perception it doesn’t do enough for player safety.
As proof: Last week, Dr. Allen Sills, the league’s chief medical officer, said the “hip-drop” technique could be eliminated. Via ProFootballTalk.com and The Washington Post, the NFL’s competition committee is expected to look at new rules preventing that type of play, and Sills and the league’s medical staff would be involved in those discussions as well.
The notion that such a play would draw a penalty was met with praise from running backs such as Green Bay’s Aaron Jones. Baltimore Ravens running back Kenyan Drake has been complaining about the practice for over a year.
Graphic Video Warning: The #NFL needs to look at this specific style of tackling. They are throwing flags for taunting and protecting qbs from getting touched but this is my 2nd straight season being injured by a guy pulling me back and using his body weight to roll up my legs. pic.twitter.com/zgJt4rM9yG
— Kenyan Drake™ (@KDx32) December 6, 2021
But the wave of negative reaction from NFL players on the defensive side of the ball was overwhelming.
NFL players reaction... not loving it to say the least. pic.twitter.com/XecXQ54jM2
— Dov Kleiman (@NFL_DovKleiman) February 4, 2023
One of those voices was from Steelers defensive end — and player rep — Cameron Heyward.
This is so stupid. How the heck are we ever going to get guys on the ground. They thinking too much
— Cam Heyward (@CamHeyward) February 4, 2023
I agree with almost every word Heyward said. Implementing a rule like this would make the act of playing defense nearly impossible.
As if it isn’t already.
Moreover, if hip-drop tackles become penalties, the weekly controversies over how many are called — and how inconsistent the calls are — will lead to chaos. It’ll look just like when the league tried to implement review of pass interference.
The only point from Heyward that I’ll quibble with is his suggestion that the NFL executives are “thinking too much.”
Honestly, Cam, they aren’t thinking. At all. They are reacting in knee-jerk fashion. If they were thinking, they’d understand that trying to officiate such a rule change would be a circus.
I understand the quest to expand player-safety measures. I do. But how much more expansive can it get? Defenders already can’t hit high. They can’t go low on the quarterback. They can’t drag anyone down from behind. They can’t land with their full body weight on a quarterback. They have to analyze in a nanosecond who is, and isn’t, a “defenseless receiver.” They can’t breathe on anyone who is within a country mile of the sidelines.
What else are they supposed to do?
More sports
• Steelers lose senior defensive assistant Brian Flores to Vikings
• A trade scenario Ron Hextall is looking to avoid and some Penguins history he may want to replicate
• NIL questions emerge after Jim Boeheim's comments, but Pitt's Jeff Capel focuses on his team
Attempting to write this rule clearly within the bounds of legal tackling will be a nebulous mess. Asking the officials to adjudicate this rule in real time on every tackle inbounds throughout the course of a game will be a nightmare. They have too much to do already.
Efforts to placate the pandering social media calls for increased player safety have gone too far. Many of those “fans” and media members don’t even really care about player safety anyway. They just are just virtue signalers fishing for likes and retweets.
The pendulum needs to swing back toward the understanding that voluntary risk is involved in football. Tackle football, especially at the NFL level, is an inherently unsafe game. It can’t be litigated into a safe space.
Heyward understands that. Let’s hope Roger Goodell figures it out.
Soon.
Tim Benz is a Tribune-Review staff writer. You can contact Tim at tbenz@triblive.com or via X. All tweets could be reposted. All emails are subject to publication unless specified otherwise.
Remove the ads from your TribLIVE reading experience but still support the journalists who create the content with TribLIVE Ad-Free.