EXCLUSIVE: Trump's move to bus immigrants to sanctuary cities could actually HELP migrants by putting them in courts where judges are more likely to grant them asylum, experts reveal

  • Sanctuary cities, counties and states are regions where officials have passed laws to protect immigrants who are in the country illegally - for example by limiting cooperation between ICE and local law enforcement 
  • Trump's proposal to bus immigrants to sanctuaries could have an unintended effect by relocating migrants to immigration court districts where judges are statistically more likely to grant asylum, experts say
  • Trump's idea could backfire because the likelihood of whether an immigrant's asylum application will be successful varies dramatically depending on the state in which their case is heard, federal data shows
  • Many sanctuary cities are home to court districts that are statistically more likely to approve asylum claims 
  • For example, New York – a sanctuary city – was the most likely to welcome asylum seekers, with only 34% denied in 2018, while immigration judges in North Carolina and Georgia had a 96% denial rate

Advertisement

Donald Trump's proposal to bus immigrants to sanctuaries could have an unintended effect by relocating migrants to immigration court districts where judges are statistically more likely to grant asylum, according to multiple immigration experts and attorneys.

One major reason Trump's idea could backfire is that the likelihood of whether an immigrant's asylum application will be successful varies dramatically depending on the state in which their case is heard – and many of the courts that tend to favor granting asylum are located in sanctuary cities, said former immigration Judge Jeffrey S. Chase.

For example, New York – a sanctuary city – was the most likely to welcome asylum seekers, with only 34 percent denied in 2018, while immigration judges in North Carolina and Georgia had a 96 percent denial rate.

'It not only gets them to the districts that have better courts and judges, but it gets them to where the pro bono lawyers and (immigration assistance) clinics are,' Chase told DailyMail.com.

Scroll down for the full list 

This map, created by the Center for Immigration Studies using ICE data, highlights the locations of sanctuary cities, counties and states around the United States. Yellow markers represent sanctuary counties, while red ones represent cities and green represent states

This map, created by the Center for Immigration Studies using ICE data, highlights the locations of sanctuary cities, counties and states around the United States. Yellow markers represent sanctuary counties, while red ones represent cities and green represent states

'A lot of times when people do bond out they head straight to New York and San Francisco anyway, so they're saving them the bus ticket,' he added.

A Department of Homeland Security official declined to comment to DailyMail.com. 

Sanctuary cities, counties and states are regions where officials have decided to pass laws that tend to protect immigrants who are in the country illegally. 

For example, some sanctuary cities refuse to allow local law enforcement to hand people over to ICE after the immigrants were arrested on minor violations.

They were largely established and gained traction under the Obama administration as local officials sought to assert their own authority on immigration issues. 

Trump has proposed busing immigrants to sanctuary cities because he says the mostly Democratic safe havens for migrants should be 'very happy' to take in people who have entered the country illegally.

It remains unclear if the White House will go through with the proposal, which the president said the administration was still strongly considering in a series of tweets on April 12.  

The likelihood of whether an immigrant's application will be successful varies dramatically depending on the state in which their case is heard. New York was the most likely to welcome asylum seekers, with only 34 percent denied in 2018, while immigration judges in North Carolina and Georgia had a 96 percent denial rate

The likelihood of whether an immigrant's application will be successful varies dramatically depending on the state in which their case is heard. New York was the most likely to welcome asylum seekers, with only 34 percent denied in 2018, while immigration judges in North Carolina and Georgia had a 96 percent denial rate

'Due to the fact that Democrats are unwilling to change our very dangerous immigration laws, we are indeed, as reported, giving strong considerations to placing illegal immigrants in sanctuary cities only,' Trump tweeted.

He added: 'The Radical Left always seems to have an Open Borders, Open Arms policy – so this should make them very happy!'

Sanctuary cities, counties and states are scattered across the Midwest, but mostly concentrated in the Northeast, Northwest and California – regions where courts tend to grant asylum at higher rates. There can be variation at the local level, for instance: Seattle is a sanctuary city, but the court there has a higher asylum denial rate than the court in Tacoma, Washington, just 40 miles south, which is not a sanctuary city. 

Tweets by Donald Trump reveal he still wants to explore the option of busing immigrants to sanctuary cities

Tweets by Donald Trump reveal he still wants to explore the option of busing immigrants to sanctuary cities

The existence of these sanctuary cities has frustrated the president in his efforts to tackle illegal immigration in the interior of the U.S.

Now growing numbers at the border have forced the administration to release many immigrants into the country immediately. Border crossings were up to 103,492 in March – a 77.5 percent increase compared to January, according to federal data. 

As a result, Trump suggested it makes sense to send those migrants to the cities that purport to welcome them.

White House officials tried to walk back the president's statements on the busing idea, however Trump responded by doubling down on the concept in his April 12 tweets.  

But his proposed tactic could hit a number of snags.

'There absolutely could be a positive outcome (for immigrants bused to) court districts that tend to be more lenient with asylum claims,' immigration policy analyst Alex Nowrasteh, of the Cato Institute, told DailyMail.com. 'That's in addition to the fact that these sanctuary cities are where a lot of the jobs and growth are for immigrants. They get a free ride and a higher chance of more favorable outcomes.'

In this April 5, 2019 file photo, President Donald Trump participates in a roundtable on immigration and border security in Calexico, California. Trump said he is considering sending 'illegal immigrants' to Democratic strongholds to punish them for 'inaction' just hours after White House and Homeland Security officials said the idea was dead on arrival

In this April 5, 2019 file photo, President Donald Trump participates in a roundtable on immigration and border security in Calexico, California. Trump said he is considering sending 'illegal immigrants' to Democratic strongholds to punish them for 'inaction' just hours after White House and Homeland Security officials said the idea was dead on arrival

Daniel Brown, a Washington D.C.-based immigration attorney with Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy, LLP, said that the Trump administration would likely be creating an even longer court backlog in those areas.

The result: more immigrants in sanctuary cities would be allowed to remain in the U.S. for longer as they await their day in court.

'Not only might it help people in terms of whether they get granted asylum, but it could also essentially be helping them with having cases that go on much longer,' Brown told DailyMail.com.

However, immigration courts that have been historically more likely to grant asylum may not be as favorable to immigrants from Central America – who currently make up the majority of people crossing the border right now, said Leon Rodriguez, an immigration attorney and former director of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services under Obama.

The reason is down to a legal opinion issued by former Jeff Sessions that says immigrants fleeing gang violence and domestic violence can't be granted asylum – which is the basis for many cases brought by immigrants from Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador.

'The Department of Justice has really, really narrowed the options for relief that the folks from South America will be presenting,' Rodriguez told DailyMail.com.

However, Chase, a former immigration judge, notes that despite Session's decision, some migrants are still winning asylum on cases seeking relief from gang violence and domestic violence – and it's mostly happening in sanctuary cities.  

Aside from the court implications, there is no guarantee that asylum seekers who were bused to these sanctuary regions would stay in the cities, said Jorge Loweree, director of policy at the American Immigration Council.

'There is some data available to support the idea that immigration courts located in or near cities with sanctuary policies are friendlier to asylum seekers (but) the (Trump) administration will not be able to force asylum seekers relocated under this proposed policy to remain in these jurisdictions,' he told DailyMail.com.

'Many of them would likely relocate to other parts of the country to be near family or friends,' he added.

This graph shows the increase in immigrants coming across the Southern U.S. border, including those who cross illegally and those who present themselves at legal checkpoints. Each line represents the first six months of a different fiscal year, with 2019 already seeing a sharp uptick

This graph shows the increase in immigrants coming across the Southern U.S. border, including those who cross illegally and those who present themselves at legal checkpoints. Each line represents the first six months of a different fiscal year, with 2019 already seeing a sharp uptick

Loweree and others said the busing proposal was a 'ploy' to antagonize liberals and immigration advocates.

'It's one of those emotionally satisfying things that causes left wingers to expose themselves as hypocrites,' said Mark Krikorian, executive director of the anti-immigration Center for Immigration Studies.

'As a messaging tactic it's really useful but it's not a realistic policy proposal, because why would we spend taxpayer money to deliver illegal immigrants to the interior?' he told DailyMail.com.

'Politically it's a smart point to bring up, so I don't think the president committed a gaffe or anything,' he added. 'I just don't think when they look at the full policy implications they will actually go through it.'

In addition, the government likely can't afford to implement the busing policy, said Sarah Pierce, an attorney and policy analyst for the Migration Policy Institute.

'One piece of evidence that shows how unlikely this is, is that ICE doesn't have the resources to process people along the border,' Pierce told DailyMail.com. 

'People are being released and never handed over to ICE so the idea that they could then expend resources busing immigrants across the country is far-fetched,' she added.

However if the administration did go through with the proposal, it could make it easier for immigrants to avoid being caught by Immigration and Customs Enforcement in a sanctuary city, Pierce noted.  

'If these individuals do decide not to show up to court and try to evade enforcement, their chances of being caught and put into deportation proceedings are higher in a jurisdiction like Georgia than one like California, for example,' she said.  

Full list of all U.S. sanctuary cities, counties and states 

 States

California

Colorado

Illinois

Massachusetts

New Jersey

New Mexico

Oregon

Vermont

Cities and Counties

California

Alameda County

Berkley

Contra Costa County

Los Angeles County

Los Angeles

Monterey County

Napa County

Oakland

Riverside County

Sacramento County

San Bernardino County

San Diego County

San Francisco

San Francisco County

San Mateo County

Santa Ana

Santa Clara County

Santa Cruz County

Sonoma County

Watsonville

Colorado

Arapahoe County

Aurora

Boulder County

Denver

Denver County

Garfield County

Grand County

Jefferson County

Larimer County

Mesa County

Pitkin County

Pueblo County

Routt County

San Miguel County

Weld County

Connecticut

East Haven

Hartford

Florida

Alachua County

Georgia

Clayton County

DeKalb County

Iowa

Benton County

Cass County

Fremont County

Greene County

Ida County

Iowa City  

Johnson County

Jefferson County

Marion County

Monona County

Montgomery County

Pottawattamie County

Sioux County 

Illinois

Chicago 

 Illinois (continued)

Cook County 

Kansas

Butler County

Harvey County 

Louisiana

New Orleans

Massachusetts

Amherst

Boston

Cambridge

Concord

Lawrence

Newton

Northhampton

Somerville

Maryland

Baltimore

Montgomery County

Prince George's County

Michigan

Ingham County

Kalamazoo County

Kent County

Wayne County

Minnesota

Hennepin County

Mississippi

Jackson

Nebraska

Hall County

Sarpy County

New Jersey

Newark

New Mexico

Bernalillo County

New Mexico County Jails 

San Miguel

Nevada

Washoe County

New York

Albany

Franklin County

Ithaca

Nassau County

New York City

Onondaga County

St. Lawrence County

Wayne County

North Carolina

Buncombe County

Durham County

Forsyth County

Mecklenburg County

Orange County

Wake County

Ohio

Franklin County

Oregon

Baker County

Clackamas County

Clatsop County

Coos County

Crook County

Curry County

Deschutes County

Douglas County

Gilliam County

Grant County

Hood River County

Jackson County

 Oregon (continued)

Jefferson County

Josephine County

Lane County

Lincoln County

Linn County

Malheur County

Marion County

Marlon County

Multnomah County

Polk County

Sherman County

Springfield

Tillamok County

Umatilla County

Union County

Wallowa County

Wasco County

Washington County

Wheeler County

Yamhill County

Pennsylvania

Bradford County

Bucks County

Butler County

Chester County

Clarion County

Delaware County

Erie County

Franklin County

Lehigh County

Lycoming County

Montgomery County

Montour County

Perry County

Philadelphia

Pike County

Westmoreland County

Rhode Island

Providence

Rhode Island Department of Corrections

Virginia

Arlington County

Chesterfield County

Fairfax County

Vermont

Burlington

Montpelier

Winooski

Washington

Chelan County

Clallam County

Clark County

Cowlitz County

Franklin County

Jefferson County

King County

Kitsap County

Pierce County

San Juan County

Skagit County

Snohomish County

Spokane County

Seattle

Thurston County

Walla Walla County

Wallowa County

Whatcom County

Yakima County

Source: Center for Immigration Studies and Immigration and Customs Enforcement data 

Advertisement

 

The comments below have been moderated in advance.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.